Navigating Fair Housing in Digital Advertising - Ensuring Non-Discriminatory Ad Delivery

person A.J. Johnson today 05/25/2024

Introduction: The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development's Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity has released crucial guidance on how the Fair Housing Act applies to digital advertising in the housing and real estate sectors. ​ With the increasing use of automated systems and artificial intelligence (AI) in ad targeting and delivery, it is essential to understand the potential risks of discriminatory practices and take proactive measures to ensure fairness.

Understanding the Risks: It's crucial to grasp how new technologies enable advertisers to target specific audiences while excluding others, potentially leading to discrimination in housing-related ads. ​ The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination based on protected characteristics such as race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, or disability. By understanding these risks, you can proactively ensure fairness and avoid potential legal issues.

Discriminatory ad targeting can manifest in various ways, including denying information about housing opportunities, targeting vulnerable consumers for predatory products, discouraging potential consumers, and steering home-seekers to specific neighborhoods. ​

Audience Targeting Tools: ​ Ad platforms offer audience categorization tools that segment potential audiences based on various characteristics like gender, age, income, and location. ​ While these tools can be useful, they can also lead to discrimination if used to exclude or target specific groups based on protected characteristics. Advertisers and platforms should be cautious when utilizing these tools for housing-related ads and avoid segmenting audiences based on protected characteristics or proxies. ​

Custom and Mirror Audience Tools: ​​ Custom and mirror audience tools allow advertisers to target specific audiences or find similar audiences based on existing data. ​ However, if protected characteristics limit the source audience, these tools can perpetuate discrimination. ​ Advertisers and platforms should carefully analyze the composition of source lists and ensure they are not unjustifiably limited based on protected characteristics. ​ Regular audits of ad delivery outcomes can help identify and mitigate discriminatory practices. ​

Algorithmic Delivery Functions: ​​ Ad platforms employ machine learning and AI to determine which ads are delivered to consumers. ​ However, these algorithmic delivery functions can also result in discriminatory outcomes. ​ Ad platforms should ensure their algorithms do not direct housing-related ads based on protected characteristics, leading to steering, pricing discrimination, or other discriminatory practices. ​ Regular testing and adjustments are necessary to minimize disparities and ensure fairness.

Recommendations for Advertisers and Platforms: ​​ Advertisers need to utilize platforms that actively manage the risk of discriminatory practices to ensure non-discriminatory ad delivery. ​  ​ Ad platforms, on the other hand, play a crucial role in this process. They should create separate processes for housing-related ads, avoid targeting options based on protected characteristics, conduct regular testing, adopt less discriminatory alternatives for AI models, ensure fair pricing practices, and maintain transparency through documentation and auditing. Ad platforms can contribute significantly to fair housing practices by fulfilling these responsibilities.

Conclusion: By diligently following the guidance provided by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, advertisers and ad platforms can contribute to fair housing practices and mitigate the perpetuation of discrimination in digital advertising. This commitment to fairness ensures compliance with the law and fosters a more inclusive and equitable digital advertising landscape. ​ It is crucial to be aware of the risks, implement proactive measures, and work towards non-discriminatory ad delivery to ensure equal access to housing opportunities for all.

Latest Articles

HUD Issues New Guidance on Solar and Rooftop Leases for Multifamily Housing

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) has released new guidance on solar, cell tower, and rooftop leases for HUD-assisted and HUD-insured multifamily housing projects. This guidance aims to streamline the process for property owners to enter into these commercial lease agreements while protecting HUD's interests. Key Points Applicability: The notice applies to owners of HUD-insured or HUD-subsidized multifamily projects subject to a HUD business agreement requiring approval for encumbrances, including commercial leases. Types of Leases Covered: Solar leases and Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) Cell tower leases Other rooftop commercial leases Ground-mounted solar electric systems Required Documentation: Owners must submit a package to their HUD Account Executive, including: Unexecuted lease agreement Estimated annual lease payments Signed HUD Multifamily Rooftop Lease Owner Self-Certification Unsigned HUD Multifamily Solar, Cell Tower, and Rooftop Lease Rider Recent roof inspection records (for rooftop systems) Mortgagee approval (for FHA-insured properties) Estimated electricity cost savings (for solar systems) HUD Review Process: HUD will review the owner's standing and compliance Local HUD counsel will review the legal aspects of the lease The Multifamily Asset Management Division Director will grant approval Post-Approval Requirements: Execute and submit the HUD Multifamily Solar, Cell Tower, and Rooftop Lease Rider Ensure adequate property insurance coverage Increase Reserve Fund for Replacements deposits if necessary Perform utility consumption and emissions benchmarking (for solar on HUD-assisted projects) Adjust utility allowances if applicable (for solar on HUD-assisted projects) Key Considerations: Roof condition and remaining useful life The project's capacity to support rooftop equipment Financing plan for equipment removal/reinstallation during roof replacement Insurance coverage for potential damages Implications for Property Owners This guidance clearly outlines a pathway for multifamily housing owners to leverage their rooftop space for additional income or energy cost savings. By outlining specific requirements and processes, HUD aims to facilitate the adoption of solar energy and other rooftop uses while safeguarding the interests of the properties, tenants, and HUD's investments. Property owners should review the entire notice carefully and consult with their HUD Account Executives when considering entering these lease agreements. The potential benefits of reduced energy costs and additional income should be weighed against the responsibilities and requirements outlined in the guidance. Due to potential tax ramifications, owners of LIHTC properties that are layered with the relevant HUD programs should consult tax counsel before executing any agreements for the use of roof space. Conclusion HUD's new guidance represents a significant step in supporting the adoption of clean energy technologies and maximizing the utility of multifamily housing properties. By providing a clear framework for approval and implementation, HUD enables property owners to explore innovative ways to reduce costs and generate income, ultimately contributing to the sustainability and financial health of the multifamily housing sector.

A. J. Johnson to Participate in 29th Annual Mid-Atlantic AHMA Fall Conference

A. J. Johnson will participate in the Mid-Atlantic Affordable Housing Management Association (AHMA) 29th Annual Fall Conference, which will take place in Richmond, VA, from November 19-21, 2024. This year's conference promises to be invaluable for professionals in the affordable housing industry, offering a comprehensive program that addresses both current challenges and future trends.  Highlights of the Conference: 1. HOTMA Implementation and Beyond While the Housing Opportunity Through Modernization Act (HOTMA) remains a focal point, this year's conference expands its scope to cover many pressing issues in affordable housing management. Attendees will gain insights on HOTMA implementation and other critical topics that impact their daily operations. 2. Diverse Learning Tracks  The conference features multiple specialized tracks to cater to various roles and interests within the industry:  - General Interest Track  - LIHTC Track  - HUD Track  - Special Interest Track  - Maintenance Workshop Track  3. Expert-Led Sessions  Renowned industry experts, including A. J. Johnson, Jenny DeSilva, and Dr. Dori Bryan-Ployer, will lead sessions on topics such as conflict resolution, marketing strategies, cyber awareness, and the impact of HOTMA on different housing programs. 4. A. J. Johnson will lead a discussion on Hot Topics in Affordable Housing Sessions and will cover crucial subjects like:  - Assistance animals and medical marijuana policies  - Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) compliance  - Fair housing in the age of artificial intelligence  - Dealing with the Death of a Resident  - Preventing Sexual Harassment  - HOTMA Income and Asset Issues  - Management of Layered Projects  5. Other Topics Featuring Industry Leaders such as Jenny DeSilva and Angelique Napoleon will include: - EIV/TRACS and HOTMA  - Understanding Human Trafficking  6. Hands-On Maintenance Workshops  A dedicated track for maintenance professionals offers practical sessions on HVAC systems, motor operations, and effective preventative maintenance planning.  7. Networking Opportunities  The conference includes a vendor exhibition and reception, providing ample opportunities for attendees to connect with peers and industry suppliers.  8. Keynote Address  The event starts with a keynote address titled "Embrace Uncommon Sense: Boost Workplace Engagement and Wellbeing," which sets an inspiring tone for the conference.  Who Should Attend:  This conference is essential for property managers, compliance officers, maintenance supervisors, asset managers, and anyone involved in the affordable housing industry. Whether you're dealing with LIHTC, HUD programs, or mixed-finance properties, there's something valuable for every professional.  Take advantage of this opportunity to stay ahead in the ever-evolving world of affordable housing management. Join us for three days of learning, networking, and professional growth at the Mid-Atlantic AHMA 2024 Fall Conference.  Register now at mid-atlanticahma.org to secure your spot at this premier industry event!

Rural Development Issues Emergency Call System Guidance

The Rural Housing Service (RHS) has issued an Unnumbered Letter providing guidance to Multifamily Housing (MFH) staff and program participants regarding emergency call systems, also referred to as "pullcords in MFH units. Installing and using emergency call systems in MFH units, commonly in bathrooms and bedrooms, have historically provided a means for tenants to alert others if they require assistance in the case of an emergency, such as a fall, fire, or medical issue. Many installed emergency call systems no longer function and provide a false sense of security, leading tenants to believe the system will directly alert emergency response services or property management. Additionally, the need for emergency call systems has diminished due to the availability and advancements in technology, such as cell phones and personal medical/life alert equipment. The purpose of the Unnumbered Letter is to inform RHS staff and property operators that RHS does not require emergency call systems in any MFH units. However, some MFH properties still have these systems. Rural Development requires the system to be operational if an emergency call system is in place in any unit. MFH properties that continue to utilize emergency call systems must ensure that the systems work as designed. The system must be regularly inspected per state and local laws. If a property previously used an emergency call system and it is no longer operational, the inoperable system must be removed. Owners and managers are responsible for ensuring that tenants understand how the emergency call system functions. It is recommended that owners provide written instructions and a demonstration of the system to tenants. Recommendations include: Step-by-step instructions on how to use the system. Guidance to tenants on what services are available in response to the system activation, including clarification that the system is not tied to and, therefore, not a substitute for 911 emergency services. Clearly marked features of the system in each unit. Steps on how to correct a false alarm if the system is accidentally activated or misused by residents or visitors. Steps on how to report problems with the emergency call system. In conclusion, while the Rural Housing Service (RHS) no longer mandates the installation of emergency call systems in Multifamily Housing (MFH) units, properties that choose to maintain these systems must ensure they are fully operational and regularly inspected. As advancements in personal alert technology provide reliable alternatives, MFH property owners and managers should prioritize educating tenants on the limitations and proper use of existing emergency call systems. This approach not only helps prevent misunderstandings about the system s capabilities but also enhances tenant safety by encouraging the use of more effective emergency response options.

2025 Social Security COLA Announced

The federal government announced on October 10, 2024, that the Social Security Cost of Living Adjustment (COLA) for 2025 will be 2.5%, slightly lower than the 3.2% increase for 2024. This increase will provide an additional $50 per month for the average retiree. Social Security recipients will receive a notice in the mail in early December showing their new benefit amount. Recipients will see an increase in their January 2025 payment. Those receiving SSI will see the increase on December 31, 2024. Owners and managers of properties required to determine residents' incomes should use the new COLA SS rate when projecting applicants' and residents' incomes. This also affects individuals receiving SSI, VA pensions, Civil Service pensions, and Railroad retirement.

Want news delivered to your inbox?

Subscribe to our news articles to stay up to date.

We care about the protection of your data. Read our Privacy Policy.